Students, Staff and Faculty: Submit Instances of Bias Found Here!
(Students can enter to win a $50 gift card with each submission! Lottery drawing each quarter.)
Submit Here!
- Critically appraise assigned course materials for instances of bias (e.g. textbooks, videos, articles, etc.)
- Submit instances of bias found using the above “SUBMIT HERE!” link
- Important Tips:
- Focus on course materials produced outside of the UW School of Nursing (SON)
- To provide feedback on course materials produced inside UW SON, see Memo 36
- Learn how to critically appraise course materials for instances of bias below
- Reduce harm to students, staff, faculty, and patients from BIPOC and other historically marginalized communities
- Equip graduates with skills to identify and dismantle structural racism and other forms of oppression as it manifests in text, visual and audio media
- Influence publishers to align content with anti-racist and diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) principles
- Support alignment of UW School of Nursing curriculum with anti-racist and DEI principles
- Use anonymized data collected for a Quality Improvement project related to anti-racism and equity in nursing
“Racism and discrimination are deeply embedded in U.S. society and its institutions, and the nursing profession is no exception. Nurse leaders can play an important role in acknowledging the history of racism within the profession and in helping to dismantle structural racism and mitigate the effects of discrimination and bias on health” (NASEM, 2021, p.11).
This project aligns with goals stated by the:
- AACN/ANA/AONL/NCSBN/NLN
- American Academy of Colleges of Nursing
- National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine
Use the 5 questions (O’Brien et al., 2022) listed below to critically appraise course materials for instances of bias. Click on the arrow to the right of each question to learn more. We are highlighting resources created for educators because you will all be in positions to educate on health equity in the environments you work in after graduation – whether in the clinic, hospital, classroom, research, or policy development setting.
Excerpt from Anti-Racism and Race Literacy: A Primer and Toolkit for Medical Educators (O’Brien et al., 2022):
Take stock of representation in your case examples, images, questions, panel speakers, and invited lecturers. The choice of who is represented and how can reinforce associations that seed bias that impacts students’ clinical reasoning, breadth of history taking, and communication, which in turn harms future patients. Representation may signal educators’ priorities and values, which can impact the learning climate by influencing how learners view themselves and their communities, or by triggering stereotype threat. In addition to race, consider representation of other identities including gender, age, sexual orientation, ability, etc. (O’Brien et al., 2022, p. 25).
Watch the video below to view a demonstration of using this question. This is an excerpt from the Project History Video.
Excerpt from Anti-Racism and Race Literacy: A Primer and Toolkit for Medical Educators (O’Brien et al., 2022):
Race is a sociopolitical construct developed to stratify groups of people in order to privilege some (white people) at the expense of others (people of color). Biology-based definitions were mapped onto race to legitimize social subjugation and exploitation along constructed racial hierarchies. While both genetic predisposition and social forces like racism contribute to health outcomes, genetic predisposition to disease cannot be inferred from one’s race so racial disparities in health outcomes cannot be attributed to biology in the absence of discussion of genetic ancestry. Observed biologic differences that fall along socially constructed racial lines are more likely driven by sociopolitical inequities (e.g. access to health care, poverty, discriminatory law and policies, etc.) and racism. Thus, race is not a biological risk factor for disease, but rather a crude proxy for the risk conferred by exposure to racism. Contextualize race in the social history as a social determinant of health and use ancestry to capture genetic predisposition (O’Brien et al., 2022, p. 26).
Watch the video below to view a demonstration of using this question. This is an excerpt from the Project History Video.
Excerpt from Anti-Racism and Race Literacy: A Primer and Toolkit for Medical Educators (O’Brien et al., 2022):
Find them, fix them! Stereotypes function consciously or unconsciously as a heuristic [mental shortcut] that guides perception, interpretation, storage and retrieval of information, especially in conditions of high cognitive demand [such as in the healthcare setting]. Racialized stereotypes dehumanize and can dangerously narrow clinical reasoning by seeding bias, influencing our expectations, inferences, impressions, and limiting our ability to see others as unique individuals. Stereotypes are conveyed through the physical traits, names, abilities, linguistic patterns, roles, experiences, behaviors, code words, and illnesses you’ve associated with race. Your ability to detect these moments depends on your sensitivity to stereotypes and your blind spots, which we all have (O’Brien et al., 2022, p. 27).
Watch the video below to view a demonstration of using this question. This is an excerpt from the Project History Video.
Excerpt from Anti-Racism and Race Literacy: A Primer and Toolkit for Medical Educators (O’Brien et al., 2022):
Begin to disrupt racism by centering and prioritizing one of its consequences – health disparities. Scrutinizing racism as a driver of disparities helps prepare students to address the consequences of racism and fosters an equitable learning environment. Teaching content from the lens of those most impacted (those experiencing disparities) ensures that historically neglected voices are not overlooked while still allowing for discussion of pathophysiology, epidemiology, clinical presentation, treatment, etc. Avoid implying that individual behaviors are to blame for disparities. Instead zoom out and contextualize disparities in the structural forces driving them in order to identify root causes and opportunities for intervention, broaden clinical reasoning, and uncouple race from false notions of pathology due to innate racial differences (O’Brien et al., 2022, p. 28).
Watch the video below to view a demonstration of using this question. This is an excerpt from the Project History Video.
Excerpt from Anti-Racism and Race Literacy: A Primer and Toolkit for Medical Educators (O’Brien et al., 2022):
“Reflect on who benefits from or is burdened by the content, message, and perspectives represented in your materials. Consider the immediate and downstream impact on learners, patients (present and future), families, communities, staff, and colleagues” (O’Brien et al., 2022, p. 20).
Watch the video below to view a demonstration of using this question. This is an excerpt from the Project History Video.
Project Stats:
Instances of bias submitted are, anonymously:
-
- Shared with Publishers biannually (January & July), to request alignment of content with anti-racist & DEI principles
- Shared with Faculty quarterly, by their respective courses, to assist the iterative alignment of curriculum with anti-racist & DEI principles
- Used for Quality Improvement Projects led by Assistant Teaching Professor Dr. Joycelyn Thomas – more information about this available here soon.
More details available here soon.
- Kahlea Williams (she/her), Operations Manager, Manning Price Spratlen Center for Anti-Racism and Equity in Nursing (MPS CARE)
- Emily Leaver (she/her), MN, ARNP, FNP-BC, DNP student, Lecturer
- Joycelyn Thomas (she/her), DNP, ARNP, FNP-BC, FNP Track Lead, Assistant Teaching Professor
- Bethany Rolfe Witham (she/her), DNP, ARNP, FNP-BC, DNP Program Director, Assistant Teaching Professor
- Monica McLemore (she/her), PhD, MPH, RN, Professor, Interim Director MPS CARE
- UW School of Nursing Anti-Racism & DEI Teaching Institute
- Rebecca O’Connor (she/her), PhD, RN
- Jamie Young (she/her/they/them), DNP, ARNP, FNP-BC
- Tara Gorstein, (she/her), UW BSN student
- Jillian Mullen (she/her), UW SoN Instructional Technologist
- Matthew Welch, (he/him), UW SoN Instructional Technologist
- Jennifer Sonney (she/her), PhD, ARNP, PPCNP-BC
- Butch de Castro (he/him), PhD, MSN/MPH, RN
- Nicole Moore (she/her), MPS CARE Strategic Brand & Communications Consultant
- LJ Norman (he/him), UW SoN UX Designer
National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. (2021). The future of nursing 2020-2030: Charting a path to achieve health equity. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/25982
O’Brien, M., Fields, R., & Jackson, A. (2022, June 14). Anti-racism and race literacy: A primer and toolkit for medical educators. UCSF School of Medicine. https://medschool.ucsf.edu/differences-matter/action-groups/focus-area-3
We welcome questions or feedback about the Anti-Racism & DEI Course Materials Project:
ar-dei-project@uw.edu
September, 2024